Sell your Tesla
CarMax said $24,600. Carvana said $29,000. Same Tesla, same week.
That's a real spread on one real car this month. Text us your VIN and a few photos — we get you a licensed Central Florida dealer's number within one business hour, so you can see it next to what Tesla, CarMax and Carvana offered instead of guessing.
Or text your VIN and 4 photos to (407) 000-0000
- Real offer by text within 1 business hour
- You see every offer side by side before you decide.
- Loan payoffs and title handled, paid in 48 hours
Why one offer isn't enough
The same car gets wildly different offers. On one 2024 Model Y this month: CarMax $24,600, Tesla $27,900, Carvana $29,000. Same VIN, same week, $4,400 apart.
CarMax and Carvana price for a nationwide average. Our dealers price for a Central Florida buyer who wants your exact car this week.
Carvana's online number can drop $200–$3,000 at pickup. Our offer is made by the dealer who is actually buying it.
Most people take the first offer they get. That's the expensive mistake — not picking the wrong company, just not asking more than one.
How it works
- 1
Scan your VIN with your phone camera — we fill in the model and year for you — add mileage and 4 photos. Two minutes.
- 2
A licensed dealer texts you a firm offer within one business hour (9am–7pm ET).
- 3
Say yes: they pick up at your home or you drop off, they pay off your loan if there is one, and you're paid by wire or check at handoff.
One real car, one week in September 2026
| Option | Offer | Time to money | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tesla trade-in | $27,900 | Same day, if you're buying a Tesla | Only works as a trade; you're locked into their car |
| CarMax | $24,600 | 1–2 hours at a store, 7-day offer | Lowest of the four here, by $4,400 |
| Carvana | $29,000 | 2–5 day pickup | Highest here — but the number can move at pickup inspection |
| Kelley Blue Book trade-in | $29,620 (range $26,620–$32,620) | n/a — it's a guide, not an offer | What the book says the car is worth |
| BuyMyTesla | A real dealer's number, in 1 hour | Offer in 1 hour, paid in 48 | One more real bidder who sees your FSD status and battery, and has no transport cost |
2024 Model Y Long Range, 68,682 miles, Central Florida. Your car will be different — that's the point. Nobody can tell you who pays most for your VIN without asking all of them.
What we buy
Model 3, Model Y, Model S, Model X, Cybertruck, 2018 and newer, any mileage, any condition including cars with a loan (we pay it off and send you the difference). Leased Teslas: ask — it depends on your lease terms.